SymBio Pharmaceuticals — Looking forward to Treakisym Phase III data

SymBio is a Japanese specialty pharma company that was established in 2005 and is based in Tokyo. It in-licenses assets with proof-of-concept data for development and commercialization in Asia-Pacific, removing the need for investment in early-stage R&D. SymBio has two main assets: Treakisym (bendamustine) for blood cancers, with Asia-Pacific marketing rights out-licensed to various commercial partners; and rigosertib for a rare blood cancer, which is being investigated in a global Phase III trial in which SymBio is participating. SymBio plans to commercialize Treakisym and rigosertib via its own salesforce after 2020 in Japan. SymBio is exploring opportunities to in-license further assets during 2019. It is also looking to expand globally and it established a US-based subsidiary in 2016.

We value SymBio at $237m (¥26,828m) or $2.7/ADR, which is based on a risk-adjusted NPV analysis and includes $43m net cash at end December 2018. Our valuation includes Treakisym, where we assume sales can continue to grow for the next two years supported by additional indications that were approved in 2016, as well as risk-adjusted contributions for the relapsed/refractory (r/r) DLBCL indication for Treakisym (Phase III ongoing) and for rigosertib. Our valuation assumes that liquid Treakisym formulations will allow SymBio to maintain a greater than 75% share of the market until at least 2031 in the face of competition from powder generics from 2022 onwards.

We estimate that end December 2018 net cash of $43m should be sufficient to fund operations into H120. We model $37m of indicative debt in FY20, and note that the company may require additional funding over and above these amounts for investment in new in-licensing or M&A opportunities.

The main sensitivities for SymBio relate to the main assets and SymBio’s ability to in-license additional products in the future. For Treakisym, our estimates assume that partner Eisai can continue to grow sales over the next two years in the indications that were approved in 2016. We also expect top-line data from Treakisym in r/r DLBCL during 2019, which will be critical in shaping the future development pathway. SymBio plans to establish its own salesforce to market Treakisym and rigosertib (if approved), which will require investment into a commercial infrastructure from 2019 onwards. We estimate sales organization costs to be $15m per year.

SymBio acquired the rights to develop and commercialize Treakisym from Astellas in Japan (2005) and subsequently in China/Hong Kong, Korea, Taiwan and Singapore (April 2007). In 2008, SymBio out-licensed the marketing of Treakisym to various commercial partners (an overview of the main agreements is shown in Exhibit 2). Although precise deal terms have not been disclosed, we estimate that SymBio earns an average net margin of around 10–12% on top-line reported Treakisym sales in Asia-Pacific. SymBio intends to establish its own sales organization to market Treakisym in Japan after the current marketing arrangement with Eisai expires in December 2020.

SymBio moved to extend the lifecycle of Treakisym when it in-licensed rights to patent-protected liquid formulations of Treakisym from Eagle in September 2017. The liquid formulations are protected by patents that extend to 2031. Treakisym is likely to face competition from generic versions of the marketed FD powder formulation from June 2022, but the company expects to switch the majority of patients to the more convenient liquid formulations following the intended launch of the RTD formulation in Q121.

Encouraged by the longer Treakisym lifecycle, SymBio is investing in a Phase III study of Treakisym in r/r DLBCL patients, an indication where it reported promising results from a Phase II study in 2012. DLBCL comprises around 45% of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma (NHL) cases in Japan, and we estimate that approval in this indication could double the sales potential of Treakisym.

Taken together, the patented liquid formulations and the DLCBL Phase III justify SymBio investing in establishing its own sales organization to market Treakisym and other drugs such as rigosertib (if approved), in our view. We estimate that SymBio could earn an operating profit margin of 50% of net sales of Treakisym under a self-commercialization model, compared to an estimated margin of 10–12% of in-market top-line sales under the arrangement with Eisai. We expect the higher margin from self-commercialization of Treakisym to make SymBio profitable in 2021.

Having its own sales organization should enable SymBio to better understand and respond to market needs, positioning it to deliver the benefits of Treakisym to healthcare providers and patients. Treakisym is used in the hematology departments of approximately 900 institutions across Japan, with the top 400 institutions accounting for ~90% of sales. If rigosertib is approved for treating myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS), the top 400 institutions would similarly be expected to account for the majority of use. Therefore, SymBio would be in a position to market rigosertib (if approved) through its own sales organization for minimal additional cost. The same operation leverage would apply were SymBio to in-license or develop other hematological drugs. Establishing its own sales organization will be an important step towards achieving SymBio’s vision of establishing itself as a leading specialty pharma company.

Exhibit 3 summarizes the status of SymBio’s product pipeline. The main areas of focus are:

Key news anticipated for SymBio in 2019 includes:

The new liquid formulations of Treakisym that SymBio in-licensed from Eagle are more convenient for healthcare workers and for patients.

The first in-licensed product is an RTD liquid formulation that will significantly reduce dose preparation time, making it easier and safer for health professionals. This compares to the FD Treakisym, which has to be reconstituted before administration, a time-consuming process that carries the risk of exposing healthcare workers to cytotoxic powders and vapors.

The second in-licensed product is an RI formulation that will cut drug infusion time to 10 minutes from 60 for the current Treakisym product (and the RTD formulation).

We expect the approval pathway for the RTD Treakisym formulation to be relatively straightforward, as the same dose of drug is administered to patients in the same way, with the only difference being the way the dose is prepared. SymBio has consulted with regulators the approval pathway for the RTD formulation and is preparing a filing application. It has narrowed down the timing of the anticipated launch of the RTD product to Q121, which is towards the earlier end of its previous target of H121. A launch at this time would allow it the RTD formulation to be well established in the marketplace before the potential entry of the first FD generics in June 2022.

The RI product represents a greater change to the current treatment protocols, so approval of this product is expected to take longer. SymBio announced on 4 April 2019 that it had enrolled the first of the planned 32 patients in a clinical trial primarily aimed at confirming the safety of the RI formulation; market launch targeted in H122. We conservatively model a 95% chance of a launch of the RI product by the start of 2023.

SymBio aims to transition at least 90% of patients from currently marketed FD powder to liquid formulations by the end of 2021, and 100% by the end of 2022. We take a slightly more conservative view and model 95% of patients being switched to these products.

SymBio is seeking to add another indication for Treakisym, in the treatment of r/r DLBCL, an intermediate or high-risk form of NHL. It commenced a Phase III trial to confirm the safety and efficacy of Treakisym plus rituximab in r/r DLBCL in August 2017 and announced on 8 April 2019 that it had completed enrolment. SymBio’s mid-range plan aims to file an NDA in Q220 and is targeting a market launch in Q321, if approved, so we expect top-line data to be reported in H219. We model Phase III costs of $18m and a potential launch in H221.

DLBCL is a rapidly growing, intermediate or high-risk form of NHL, in contrast to the slower-growing indolent or low-risk lymphomas that are included in the current approvals for Treakisym.

DLBCL is the most common form of NHL and is estimated to represent 45% of NHL cases in Japan.1 Based on epidemiology studies1 and Globocan data, we estimate there will be 35,500 new cases of NHL and 16,000 new cases of DLBCL in Japan in 2020. Assuming that 70% of DLBCL patients progress to receive second-line therapy, we forecast a target market of 11,200 second-line (r/r) DLBCL patients per year in Japan by 2020.

The market of 11,200 r/r DLBCL patients in Japan is almost as large as the combined market of ~12,500 patients for the currently approved indications for Treakisym in chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) and first-line and r/r low-grade NHL and mantle cell lymphoma (MCL). Given the high unmet need for this patient group, we model a 50% market penetration and peak sales (net sales after discounts) of $85m for DLBCL vs $82m for the currently approved indications.

Japan accounts for about 95% of Treakisym sales. Japanese in-market sales of Treakisym estimated from prescription numbers and expressed on a National Health Insurance price basis grew by 11.6% to ~$75m in 2018, from $67m in the previous year. Partner Eisai reports sales on a net sales after discounts basis; on this basis Eisai reported Treakisym sales revenue of $65m in Japan itself for the 2018 calendar year (up ~12%) and total net Treakisym revenue of $67m when sales in other territories (South Korea and Singapore) were included.

SymBio books revenue equal to about 50% of net in-market Treakisym sales under the marketing agreement with Eisai. While total sales reported by SymBio in 2018 increased by 11.4% to $34m, these sales were 9% below guidance and our forecasts.

Treakisym sales have grown by ~80% over the period from 2016 to 2018, supported by approvals for two new indications for Treakisym in Japan that were received in 2016:

SymBio attributed the shortfall in 2018 sales to slower than expected market penetration in first-line treatment of low-grade NHL. As a result, it has reduced its targeted market penetration in first-line lg NHL to 70% by 2020, from its previous target of 75%.

We have adjusted our forecasts of net in-market sales of Treakisym in currently approved indications, adjusted for discounts (the form reported by Eisai), to grow by $5m in 2019 (75% of the Treakisym sales growth reported by Eisai for the 2018 calendar year) and by $5m in 2020. We forecast Treakisym sales in existing indications to peak at $76m (previously $84m) in 2021, as shown in Exhibit 5.

We model in-market Treakisym sales (net sales after discounts) in DLBCL in 2021 to be $4m, if launched in Q321 in line with the company’s targets. We estimate that sales in DLBCL could exceed the currently marketed indications by 2025, and peak at $85m in 2026, if approved (Exhibit 5).

In February, SymBio released an updated four-year plan along with its results for the 2018 financial year. The plan provides a clearer outline of the pathway to self-commercialization in 2021. Previously, in February 2018 the company foreshadowed that it was giving serious consideration to moving to self-commercialization of Treakisym, and at that time prepared its 2021 targets on the assumption that it would proceed with self-commercialization. On 16 October 2018 it announced that it had begun preparations to establish its own sales organization to sell Treakisym in Japan.

The rationale for self-commercialization is underpinned by the in-license of liquid formulations of Treakisym from Eagle Pharmaceuticals. We expect the launch of liquid formulations (if approved) to allow SymBio to maintain a dominant share of the bendamustine hydrochloride market in the face of FD powder generic which could be launched as early as June 2022.

Exhibit 6 compares the targets in the most recent four-year plan announced in February 2019 to the targets announced 12 months earlier. For 2021, we compare the new targets to the median of the old high and low targets.

The most notable revision is that the sales target for 2020 has been reduced by 23% to $29m, due to its expectation that it will discontinue shipments to Eisai around the end of H120 as it transitions the product shipment destination from Eisai to wholesalers.

Furthermore, targeted sales for 2021 are 17% below the median point of the old sales target range. The twin contributors for this are, firstly, an anticipated launch date of the DLBCL indication now three months later (Q321) and, secondly, a 5% reduction in the peak uptake of Treakisym in the first-line l/g NHL indications approved in 2016.

For the first time the company has provided performance targets for 2022. These provide the first insights as to the company’s expectations of the full-year sales potential and the costs of promoting the DLBCL indication and liquid formulations for Treakisym. We calculate targeted operating expenses to be $82m in 2022 vs $70m in 2021, with lower R&D costs due to the completion of the DLBCL Phase III trial likely partly offsetting the cost of supporting its own sales force.

SymBio in-licensed rigosertib (iv and oral formulations, Japan and Korean rights) from Onconova in 2011 for MDS, a rare blood cancer. SymBio is contributing patients from Japan to the global Phase III INSPIRE trial of iv rigosertib for the treatment of second-line higher-risk MDS (HR-MDS).

Onconova announced on 25 March 2019 that enrolment in the Phase III study has passed 75% (ie 270 patients), and that it is on track to fully enroll the target of 360 patients in H219. Onconova also expect to report top-line results of the overall survival analysis after 288 events will be available in H219. SymBio has previously said it aims to file for approval in Japan in 2021.

As of December 2018 SymBio had already reached its target of enrolling 40 patients in Japan, but it has stated that enrolment is proceeding.

Onconova said that the Independent Data Monitoring Committee had observed a promising survival signal at the interim analysis conducted in early 2018. The committee recommended that the trial continue with an expansion in enrolment to 360 patients (from 225 patients) based on a pre-planned sample size re-estimation.

SymBio in-licensed the exclusive rights to develop the IONSYS (SyB P-1501) pain patch in Japan from The Medicines Company (MDCO) in October 2015 and initiated a Phase III trial in Japan in June 2016. SymBio suspended enrolment in the trial in April 2017 due to concerns over the continuity of MDCO’s business regarding the product. The license agreement between SymBio and MDCO was terminated effective 30 November 2017 and SymBio completed the process of terminating the development of SyB P-1501 in February 2018. SymBio is seeking damages of at least $82m arising from MDCO’s repudiation of the license agreement. We do not include any potential damages in our valuation or forecasts.

SymBio is actively seeking new drug candidates and in-licensing opportunities globally, targeting drug candidates with clinically confirmed efficacy and safety. Discussions with multiple potential licensors are ongoing. If the company proceeds with its plans to establish its own salesforce in Japan, then there will be increased incentive to in-license additional products that could be marketed by the salesforce.

The company has established a US-based subsidiary, SymBio Pharma USA, as a strategic base for overseas business development. It may look to in-license or develop drugs it can commercialize on a global basis as part of a continued transformation to a global specialty pharma company.

On 28 March, shareholders voted to approve a one-for-four consolidation of the company’s common stock, which will take effect on 1 July 2019. We will not incorporate the reverse stock split into our forecasts until after it takes effect on 1 July.

SymBio is subject to the usual drug development risks, including clinical development delays or failures, regulatory risks, competitor successes, partnering setbacks, financing and commercial risks. The main sensitivities include rigosertib and DLBCL clinical trial success or failure, the ability to execute future in-licensing deals and successfully establishing its own salesforce to self-commercialize Treakisym after 2020.

For Treakisym, key risks relate to the outcome of the DLBCL Phase III trial, obtaining regulatory approval for the liquid Treakisym formulations and success in migrating patients to the liquid formulation to stave off competition from generic copies of Treakisym powder after 2021. It will have to bear the cost of establishing a salesforce before the marketing arrangement with Eisai expires.

SymBio is seeking damages from The Medicines Company arising from its repudiation of the IONSYS license agreement. We do not model any compensation payments for IONSYS, so if SymBio was to receive any compensation, this would represent the potential to recover some of the value we have now written off.

The main sensitivity for rigosertib is the outcome of the Phase III INSPIRE trial of iv rigosertib in second-line HR-MDS. Onconova may need additional cash to complete the trial and report top-line data. If it is unable to secure any additional funds that may be required, this could delay trial completion and therefore timelines. If the outcome of the trial is negative, then not only would this impact the development of iv rigosertib, but there could also be read-across to oral rigosertib.

SymBio is reliant on in-licensing further assets to fill its pipeline. We believe the CEO’s network is crucial to securing future deals, although we have limited visibility on the potential terms and timing of any such agreements.

Our valuation of SymBio is increased to $237m (¥26,828m), or $2.7/ADR, based on a risk-adjusted NPV analysis, which includes $43m net cash at end December 2018 vs $26m at the end of the previous year. We use a 10% discount rate for approved products and 12.5% elsewhere. Our valuation includes Treakisym approved indications and the new r/r DLBCL indication, plus rigosertib. We have rolled our valuation model forward to the new financial year and reduced forecast peak sales for approved Treakisym indications by 9% to $76m, following below-expectations growth in 2018.

The higher cash balance due to $38m (net) raised from the issue of shares and share acquisition rights in 2018, combined with rolling forward the model to the new financial year, has more than offset the negative impact of reduced peak sales forecast for the approved Treakisym indications.

Our main assumptions are summarized in Exhibit 7 below.

We model a 95% likelihood that the RI Treakisym formulation will be launched before the end of 2022, thereby minimizing the penetration of generic copies of the FD Treakisym formulation. We model branded Treakisym market share gradually declining from 96% in 2022 to 75% in 2031, followed by a more rapid decline from 2032 after the liquid formulation patents expire.

Our Treakisym valuation assumes that SymBio earns an average net margin of 10–12% on top-line reported Treakisym sales until 2020. We assume that after 2020 the net operating margin gradually increases to reach 50% in 2024 and subsequent years as SymBio switches to self-commercialization of Treakisym via its own salesforce and the liquid formulations in-licensed from Eagle gain market share vs powder formulations.

We model $13m of development costs to achieve approval for the RTD and RI liquid formulations. We estimate that a salesforce of 60 would be needed to market Treakisym in Japan. At a fully-loaded cost of $250,000 per person, this would cost $15m.

In a scenario where the Treakisym market share declines to 50% by 2031 (vs 75% for the base case), our valuation would fall by around $18m ($0.2/ADR) to around $220m ($2.5/ADR). We currently assume stable Treakisym pricing apart from a 5% price cut in 2022 when FD powder generics are expected to enter the market. However, an additional price cut to Treakisym in the future could represent downside to our forecasts; a 10% price cut in 2020 would remove around $23m from our Treakisym rNPV, or $0.3/ADR.

Our financial forecasts have been updated to reflect FY18 reported financials and SymBio’s updated financial guidance for 2019 and targets for 2020–2022. The main changes to our forecasts are summarised in Exhibit 8.

We have reduced forecast revenue in 2019 because 2018 sales were 9% below our expectations, and our decision to reduce our peak sales forecast for Treakisym in the approved indications to $76m from $84m (expressed as net in-market sales after discounts). We have reduced forecast revenue in 2020 by 27%, reflecting the anticipated winding down of Eisai inventory in H220 in the lead up the end of the marketing arrangement in December 2020.

We have increased R&D expenditure and reduced SG&A forecasts in 2019, broadly in line with SymBio’s guidance (Exhibit 9). We have increased forecast R&D expenditure in 2020 in line with the three-month delay in anticipated completion of the DLBCL Phase III, and have further increased forecast SG&A spend as SymBio begins to build its own salesforce in Japan.

SymBio raised $38m (net) from the issue of shares and share acquisition rights in 2018, lifting net cash at 31 December 2018 to $43m vs $26m at the end of the previous year. We estimate that the cash of $43m should be sufficient to fund operations into H120. We model $37m of indicative debt in FY20. The company may require additional funding over and above these amounts for investment in new in-licensing or M&A opportunities.