QEX continues to expand its business across New Zealand, Australia and China, with group sales up c 42% y-o-y in FY18 and the FY19 key operating milestone (KOM) target set at NZ$41m, implying c 30% y-o-y growth. The scope of future earnings improvement will depend on QEX’s ability to address pricing pressures (FY18 gross margin down to 16.1% from 17.3% in FY17) and to manage working capital and cash flow effectively as the business grows. Shares currently trade at a FY18 (year ended March-2018) EV/EBITDA ratio of 14.7x.
QEX Logistics |
Fuelling further business expansion
General industrials |
NXT Company Spotlight
6 June 2018 |
Share price graph
Share details
Business description
Bull
Bear
Analyst
QEX Logistics coverage is provided through the NXT Research Scheme |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||
QEX continues to expand its business across New Zealand, Australia and China, with group sales up c 42% y-o-y in FY18 and the FY19 key operating milestone (KOM) target set at NZ$41m, implying c 30% y-o-y growth. The scope of future earnings improvement will depend on QEX’s ability to address pricing pressures (FY18 gross margin down to 16.1% from 17.3% in FY17) and to manage working capital and cash flow effectively as the business grows. Shares currently trade at a FY18 (year ended March-2018) EV/EBITDA ratio of 14.7x.
Top-line growth remains strong
In line with its earlier announcement, QEX reported sales of NZ$31.5m, up 41.8% y-o-y. Sales of milk powder increased by 49% y-o-y to NZ$11.8m amid favourable demand trends and shortage of milk powder during the Chinese New Year season, whereas revenue from parcel delivery, logistics and customs service improved by 31.2% y-o-y to NZ$19.7m, with lower international parcel revenues in New Zealand offset by Australia and China. QEX’s recently launched Australian operations contributed NZ$2.4m to the top-line. Future revenues may be supported by the JV which is currently being established by QEX to distribute Munchkin Grass Fed Infant Formula and Munchkin Accessory products.
Some pressure on margins
QEX’s gross margin declined by c 120 bps to 16.1%, with margin on milk powder sale at 9.4% vs 10.3% in FY17. This may be the result of pricing pressures in the New Zealand international parcel business, coupled with high level of pricing sensitivity of dairy product customers. During the recent FY19 Key Operating Milestone (KOM) targets review, QEX’s gross margin target was revised slightly down from 15% to 14%. Nevertheless, gross profit increased by 31.7% y-o-y to NZ$5.1m and adjusted EBITDA rose by 8.0% to NZ$2.8m.
Valuation: Peer comparison
QEX is priced at 14.7x FY18 (end-March 2018) EV/EBITDA, with logistics companies trading on consensus multiples of c 10.1x EV/EBITDA and 22.8x P/E on a trailing 12-month basis. However, QEX’s ratio may decline further if the company meets its KOM targets for FY19.
|
Company financials
Source: QEX accounts, Note: *Preliminary numbers. **QEX’s KOM target. |
Financials: High growth/high cash consumption
QEX reported a basic EPS of NZ$2.9 cents in FY18 (period ended March 2018), which is 38.3% below the number achieved in FY17. The decline was largely a function of one-off items in FY18, including initial NXT listing expenses at NZ$0.6m and costs related to the employee share option scheme of c NZ$0.1m, as well as a one-time gain on the acquisition of the Shanghai Ditu subsidiary at NZ$47,879 in FY17.
In contrast, revenues increased considerably by 41.8% y-o-y to NZ$31.5m (and were c 21% higher than QEX’s original KOM target), driven by strong demand for dairy products during the Chinese New Year season in February and the better-than-expected performance of the Australian operations (QEX’s sales in Australia were NZ$2.4m vs none in FY17) and Chinese Ditu. Milk powder sales were up 49.0% y-o-y to NZ$19.7m in FY18, although gross margin in this segment declined to 9.4% from 10.3% in FY17. QEX has again signalled that the market for dairy products remains very competitive amid high customer sensitivity to product price, availability and freshness. QEX also sees competitive pricing pressures in New Zealand resulting in lower international parcel revenues, which was offset by new logistics revenues from Australian and Chinese clients. As a result of the above, overall gross margin was down to 16.1% from 17.3% in FY17.
QEX’s administrative and employee costs were up to NZ$3.0m from NZ$1.3m in FY17 due to the above-mentioned listing costs, higher employee expenses (both from headcount increase in New Zealand and consolidation of Shanghai Ditu), as well as costs related to the new company premises. Consequently, adjusted EBITDA rose moderately by 8.0% y-o-y to NZ$2.8m.
Exhibit 1: FY18 financial highlights
€'000s |
FY18 |
FY17 |
y-o-y change |
Revenue |
31,525 |
22,234 |
41.8% |
Revenue from parcel delivery, logistics and customs clearance |
11,832 |
9,021 |
31.2% |
Sales of milk powder |
19,693 |
13,213 |
49.0% |
Cost of sales |
(26,459) |
(18,389) |
43.9% |
Gross profit |
5,066 |
3,845 |
31.7% |
Adj. gross margin |
16.1% |
17.3% |
-122 bp |
Administrative expenses |
(1,544) |
(557) |
177.3% |
Employee benefits expenses |
(1,470) |
(725) |
102.7% |
Gain on acquisition of subsidiary |
0 |
48 |
N/M |
EBITDA |
2,052 |
2,611 |
-21.4% |
Adj. EBITDA* |
2,768 |
2,563 |
8.0% |
Adj. EBITDA margin (%) |
8.8% |
11.5% |
-275 bp |
Depreciation |
(86) |
(65) |
32.8% |
Interest received |
23 |
55 |
-58.0% |
Finance costs |
(143) |
(9) |
N/M |
PBT |
1,846 |
2,592 |
-28.8% |
Income tax expense |
(656) |
(716) |
-8.4% |
Effective tax rate (%) |
35.5% |
27.6% |
792bp |
Net income |
1,190 |
1,876 |
-36.6% |
EPS (basic, NZ$ cents) |
2.90 |
4.70 |
-38.3% |
EPS (diluted, NZ$ cents) |
2.70 |
4.70 |
-42.6% |
Source: QEX accounts. Note: *EBITDA adjustments include initial listing related costs (NZ$579,317 in FY18), share option costs (NZ$136,324 in FY18) and gain on acquisition of subsidiary (NZ$47,879 in FY17).
Despite the solid top-line momentum, QEX recorded negative cash flow from operations of -NZ$3.2m (vs NZ$0.4m in FY17) which is, apart from an increase in net interest paid and income taxes payments, largely a function of payments to suppliers and employees exceeding receipts from customers. The company’s rampant growth translated into considerable net working capital build-up from NZ$1.2m in FY17 to NZ$5.2m, with inventory and accounts payable growth outpacing group sales/COGS, while accounts payable grew broadly in line with the cost of sales. This was more than offset by new borrowings (NZ$1.6m, with net debt to adjusted EBITDA at a relatively low 0.2x in FY18), by proceeds from share issuance (NZ$2.6m) and the repayment of a loan granted to a shareholder (NZ$1.5m). However, it will be crucial for QEX to reconcile strong business growth with effective cash flow management in the current year.
Future results may be supported by the joint venture (ANZ Brand House) QEX is establishing with two other shareholders for the distribution of Munchkin Grass Fed Infant Formula and Munchkin Accessory products. Apart from a share in ANZ’s profits, QEX may also benefit from providing logistics services to the JV and access to Munchkin infant formula for QEX’s customers.
Valuation
QEX remains a small company with few peers. We note that AuMake (a recently listed Australian company) is approaching the daigou market differently, with plans to open at least 20 specialist stores in Australia targeting Chinese clients and at least 10 stores in China. It had trailing 12-month sales as at end-2017 of c A$18m and raised A$14m in January 2018. There are a number of other logistics companies globally, which average 10.1x next-year’s EV/EBITDA. As can be seen, analyst coverage of these is poor for any companies with a market cap of less than c US$700m.
Exhibit 2: Comparative multiples
Market cap |
EV/EBITDA (x) |
P/E (x) |
|
Direct |
|
||
AuMake International Ltd |
53 |
- |
- |
Milk and health supplements |
|||
a2 Milk Co Ltd |
5,488 |
25.4x |
53.9x |
Bellamy's Australia Ltd |
1,519 |
- |
- |
Blackmores Ltd |
1,989 |
28.7x |
40.7x |
Median |
|
27.0x |
47.3x |
Logistics |
|||
United Parcel Service |
100,550 |
11.4x |
18.7x |
FedEx Corp |
67,627 |
10.1x |
18.8x |
Deutsche Post |
47,709 |
10.0x |
16.1x |
Kuehne + Nagel International |
18,205 |
14.7x |
23.9x |
DSV |
15,715 |
17.5x |
29.9x |
Bollore |
14,479 |
21.8x |
23.1x |
JB Hunt Transport Services |
14,203 |
13.3x |
33.6x |
Expeditors International of Washington |
13,167 |
12.4x |
27.7x |
CH Robinson Worldwide |
12,452 |
16.2x |
25.6x |
Yamato Holdings |
11,802 |
12.3x |
- |
Nippon Express |
7,507 |
7.4x |
18.7x |
Landstar System |
4,848 |
14.6x |
26.5x |
Hyundai Glovis |
4,677 |
7.9x |
9.2x |
Sankyu |
3,582 |
7.6x |
17.7x |
Sinotrans |
3,430 |
4.9x |
12.0x |
Hitachi Transport System |
3,013 |
9.2x |
16.1x |
Panalpina Welttransport Holdin |
2,996 |
15.9x |
39.4x |
Mainfreight |
1,870 |
14.1x |
26.0x |
Forward Air Corp |
1,785 |
10.4x |
24.2x |
Hub Group |
1,773 |
10.0x |
25.1x |
Kintetsu World Express |
1,467 |
8.4x |
24.2x |
Echo Global Logistics |
790 |
14.9x |
- |
Eddie Stobart Logistics |
672 |
- |
- |
Wincanton |
461 |
5.1x |
9.1x |
Logwin |
455 |
5.5x |
13.5x |
Hanjin Transportation |
272 |
11.3x |
- |
Sebang |
252 |
6.7x |
8.9x |
K&S Corp |
164 |
5.8x |
39.7x |
Marsden Maritime Holdings |
155 |
186.1x |
22.8x |
South Port New Zealand |
123 |
10.2x |
19.0x |
TIL Logistics Group |
100 |
- |
- |
Lindsay Australia |
85 |
6.8x |
19.9x |
Bremer Lagerhaus-Gesellschaft |
60 |
- |
- |
CTI Logistics |
58 |
8.1x |
20.5x |
Hansol Logistics |
41 |
5.4x |
30.5x |
Mercantile Ports and Logistics |
14 |
- |
- |
Median |
|
10.1x |
22.8x |
Source: Edison Investment Research, Bloomberg. Note: Prices as at 31 May 2018.
|
||||||||
Research: Investment Companies
Vietnam Enterprise Investments (VEIL) was launched in 1995 and is the largest Vietnam specialist closed-ended investment company listed in London. With an unconstrained, bottom-up investment process focussing on stock selection for capital growth, the fund has delivered good near- and long-term performance; achieving an annualised NAV return of 25% over the past five years to end-May 2018. Vietnam equities have performed strongly over the past two years, and a correction since the March 2018 VN Index peak has helped to moderate valuations. Meanwhile faster than expected GDP growth of 7.4% for Q118, and a sustained robust outlook, support earnings momentum. VEIL’s discount to NAV of 14.8% is smaller than its three-year average of 16.5%, and may have scope to narrow further over time.